Serial Killer Confesses to 1981 Mt. Vernon Stabbing - KFVS12 News & Weather Cape Girardeau, Carbondale, Poplar Bluff

Mt. Vernon, IL

Serial Killer Confesses to 1981 Mt. Vernon Stabbing

Serial Killer Confesses to 1981 Mt. Vernon Stabbing
By: Carly O'Keefe

MT. VERNON, Ill. - For more than 26 years, one particular case has haunted Attorney Stephen Swafford.

"I remember this, of all the hundreds of cases I've tried, I remember this one.  And I've always thought they had the wrong guy in this case," said Swafford.

It's a case of attempted murder: People vs. Grover Thompson.  It involved a 46-year-old transient man arrested while, according to Swafford, he was simply trying to sleep in the Mt. Vernon post office between bus trips.

"The victim in this case was a sweet old lady.  It was Aunt Bee, and the jury felt a great deal of sympathy for her and they wanted to convict someone for it.  Mr. Thompson happened to be at the wrong place at the wrong time," said Swafford.

Court documents state on September 7, 1981, a man was hiding in the shower in Ida White's basement apartment located directly across the street from the Mt. Vernon Post Office.  He attacked the 73-year-old woman with a pocket knife when she came into the room.  There was a struggle.  White called for help, and the attacker stabbed her abdomen repeatedly.

In January 1982 Swafford argued that the assailant was not Grover Thompson.  Twenty-six years almost to the day later, Heartland News showed Swafford a transcript of an interview in which serial killer Timothy Krajcir confesses in vivid detail to committing the crime.

"There is no way that this man (Krajcir) could have given the detail of what happened unless he was the man who did it... I am absolutely convinced he's the man who stabbed the lady in that apartment building," said Swafford.

Court documents state Ida White never identified Thompson as her attacker.  Swafford claims the other eyewitness, Barney J. Bates, wasn't given much choice.  Thompson was the only suspect police had him view.  There was no photo array of suspects and no line up.

"I think that idea got put in his head by suggestive identification procedure.  It's a situation where it came down to that eyewitness versus Mr. Thompson's denial," said Swafford. 

There was a small amount of blood on a hunting knife found in Thompson's pocket, but court documents state crime lab technicians could not even extract enough to test what type it was.

"There should have been more blood on the knife.  There should have been blood spatter on his clothes, on his hands, on his face, none of that was present.  This eyewitness account was not corroborated by any physical evidence, but they chose to believe that eyewitness and he was wrong," said Swafford.

Unfortunately, there's no way to tell if Krajcir is telling the truth.  Both the victim, Mrs. Ida White, and Thompson have passed away.  But by coming forward, Mr. Swafford hopes to clear the name of a man he's always felt was wrongly convicted.

"It's bittersweet, sweet because I was right all these years, but it's bitter because I've seen an injustice done to a man for something he didn't do, and for it he ended up spending the rest of his life in prison," Swafford said.

Mt. Vernon Police Chief Chris Mendenall declined an on-camera interview but said he is positive the Mt. Vernon Police Department got the right man all those years ago.

  • Heartland NewsMore>>

  • Kennett, MO warehouse fire considered a total loss

    Kennett, MO warehouse fire considered a total loss

    Wednesday, August 15 2018 9:01 PM EDT2018-08-16 01:01:25 GMT
    The warehouse is where Bullock Furniture stores all of their inventory (Source: Don Frazier, KFVS)The warehouse is where Bullock Furniture stores all of their inventory (Source: Don Frazier, KFVS)

    Crews are responded to a structure fire in Kennett, Missouri on Wednesday, August 15. 

    Crews are responded to a structure fire in Kennett, Missouri on Wednesday, August 15. 

  • Marble Hill, MO police chief says town has suicide problem

    Marble Hill, MO police chief says town has suicide problem

    Wednesday, August 15 2018 8:17 PM EDT2018-08-16 00:17:00 GMT
    Chief Marc Tragesser said his department receives two to three suicide calls a week, more than he's dealt with in any other jurisdiction he's worked in. (Source: Marble Hill Police Department/Facebook)Chief Marc Tragesser said his department receives two to three suicide calls a week, more than he's dealt with in any other jurisdiction he's worked in. (Source: Marble Hill Police Department/Facebook)

    The Chief of Marble Hill says the town has a suicide problem.

    The Chief of Marble Hill says the town has a suicide problem.

  • breaking

    Large gas, water leak ongoing in Benton, IL

    Large gas, water leak ongoing in Benton, IL

    Wednesday, August 15 2018 8:15 PM EDT2018-08-16 00:15:14 GMT
    A Franklin County Emergency Management Agency Duty Officer has responded to a large gas leak. Buildings around the incident have been evacuated. (Source: Chris Drury, KFVS)A Franklin County Emergency Management Agency Duty Officer has responded to a large gas leak. Buildings around the incident have been evacuated. (Source: Chris Drury, KFVS)

    A large gas leak has caused a hazmat situation in Benton.

    A large gas leak has caused a hazmat situation in Benton.

  • Trending StoriesTrending StoriesMore>>

  • Italy hunts for blame in bridge collapse that killed 39

    Italy hunts for blame in bridge collapse that killed 39

    Wednesday, August 15 2018 3:26 AM EDT2018-08-15 07:26:11 GMT
    Wednesday, August 15 2018 8:56 PM EDT2018-08-16 00:56:06 GMT
    (Vigili Del Fuoco via AP). In this photo released by the Italian firefighters, rescue teams work among the rubble of the collapsed Morando highway bridge in Genoa, northern Italy, Tuesday, Aug. 14, 2018. A bridge on a main highway linking Italy with Fr...(Vigili Del Fuoco via AP). In this photo released by the Italian firefighters, rescue teams work among the rubble of the collapsed Morando highway bridge in Genoa, northern Italy, Tuesday, Aug. 14, 2018. A bridge on a main highway linking Italy with Fr...

    Rescue and recovery efforts continued through the night into the morning in Italy following the collapse of a highway bridge in Genoa, while authorities raised the death toll to 35 with three missing.

    Rescue and recovery efforts continued through the night into the morning in Italy following the collapse of a highway bridge in Genoa, while authorities raised the death toll to 35 with three missing.

  • Four girls fight off attacker in MI

    Four girls fight off attacker in MI

    Wednesday, August 15 2018 12:24 PM EDT2018-08-15 16:24:50 GMT

    The girls used their drinks and fists to get an attacker to leave them alone after he grabbed the youngest girl by the face.

    The girls used their drinks and fists to get an attacker to leave them alone after he grabbed the youngest girl by the face.

  • Police use DNA to identify body of Michigan boy missing since 1979

    Police use DNA to identify body of Michigan boy missing since 1979

    Wednesday, August 15 2018 2:47 PM EDT2018-08-15 18:47:44 GMT

    Andrew Jackson Greer, 15, left school on Feb. 12, 1979, and never returned home. His remains were positively identified almost 40 years later.

    Andrew Jackson Greer, 15, left school on Feb. 12, 1979, and never returned home. His remains were positively identified almost 40 years later.

Powered by Frankly