Could Funeral Protesting Church Win Appeal? - KFVS12 News & Weather Cape Girardeau, Carbondale, Poplar Bluff

Carbondale, IL

Could Funeral Protesting Church Win Appeal?

Could Funeral Protesting Church Win Appeal?
By: Carly O'Keefe

CARBONDALE, Ill. - A law professor and local ACLU chapter president says a church ordered by a federal court to pay nearly $11 million to a grieving family may have grounds for an appeal.

The lawsuit was filed by Albert Snyder of York, Pennsylvania on grounds that Westboro Baptist Church members out of Topeka, Kansas invaded his privacy and caused his family distress.  Westboro members protested the funeral of Snyder's son, a Marine killed in Iraq.            

Members of Westboro Baptist Church made their presence known in the Heartland back in June 2006.  The group protested outside the church as family and friends laid U.S. Army Sgt. Brian Romines to rest.

"It was already a bad day, made worse by their being there," said Romines' mother, Melinda Astin. 

While most don't agree with what the Westboro Baptist Church has said and done around the country, according to Southern Illinois University Law Professor Leonard Gross,church members have the right to protest.

"It's a price we pay for living in a free society.  There will be people who are going to protest in ways most of us find distasteful or worse," said Gross.

Gross said as long as the church members did not step foot on private property during their protest, they may be able to win their case if they appeal to a higher court.

"I think the protestors' point of view is despicable, but having said that, I believe it's constitutionally protected under the First Amendment," said Gross.

While Astin wants the lower court's ruling to stand, she hopes at the very least it temporarily puts a stop to the Westboro Baptist Church funeral protests.

"If it gets them off the street, that's great," said Astin. "It saves some grieving families and people who go to the service a lot of emotional trauma."

  • Heartland NewsMore>>

  • This week in music: 1984

    This week in music: 1984

    Monday, August 20 2018 7:31 AM EDT2018-08-20 11:31:50 GMT

    Let's do a little time traveling.  This morning we head back to the 80's, specifically the late summer of 1984. 

    Let's do a little time traveling.  This morning we head back to the 80's, specifically the late summer of 1984. 

  • Dorena-Hickman Ferry closed for dredging work

    Dorena-Hickman Ferry closed for dredging work

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 6:54 AM EDT2018-08-21 10:54:15 GMT
    The ferry is closed for dredging work (Source: KFVS)The ferry is closed for dredging work (Source: KFVS)

    A ferry between Kentucky and Missouri is closed this week while dredging work is completed.

    A ferry between Kentucky and Missouri is closed this week while dredging work is completed.

  • First Alert: Cool, gloomy day with scattered showers

    First Alert: Cool, gloomy day with scattered showers

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 6:44 AM EDT2018-08-21 10:44:03 GMT
    Tuesday's cool down will last through the week (Source: James Gullage of Humboldt, TN)Tuesday's cool down will last through the week (Source: James Gullage of Humboldt, TN)
    Tuesday's cool down will last through the week (Source: James Gullage of Humboldt, TN)Tuesday's cool down will last through the week (Source: James Gullage of Humboldt, TN)

    Laura Wibbenmeyer says the best rain chances will be in our northeastern half of the Heartland.

    Laura Wibbenmeyer says the best rain chances will be in our northeastern half of the Heartland.

  • Trending StoriesTrending StoriesMore>>

  • Man admits slaying wife, blames her for daughters' deaths

    Man admits slaying wife, blames her for daughters' deaths

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 12:15 AM EDT2018-08-21 04:15:23 GMT
    Tuesday, August 21 2018 8:30 AM EDT2018-08-21 12:30:18 GMT
    Christopher Watts, 33, faces three first-degree murder charges, two counts of murdering a child under 12, one count of unlawful termination of a pregnancy and three counts of tampering with a deceased human body. (Source: Weld County Sheriff/KMGH/CNN)Christopher Watts, 33, faces three first-degree murder charges, two counts of murdering a child under 12, one count of unlawful termination of a pregnancy and three counts of tampering with a deceased human body. (Source: Weld County Sheriff/KMGH/CNN)

    The father of two told police in court papers released Monday that he killed his pregnant wife after witnessing her strangling one of the girls on a baby monitor.

    The father of two told police in court papers released Monday that he killed his pregnant wife after witnessing her strangling one of the girls on a baby monitor.

  • US deports former Nazi camp guard, 95, to Germany

    US deports former Nazi camp guard, 95, to Germany

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 4:18 AM EDT2018-08-21 08:18:16 GMT
    Tuesday, August 21 2018 8:29 AM EDT2018-08-21 12:29:28 GMT
    The deportation of the 95-year-old former concentration camp guard, Jakiw Palij, came 25 years after investigators first confronted him about his World War II past and he admitted lying to get into the U.S. (Source: Department of Justice)The deportation of the 95-year-old former concentration camp guard, Jakiw Palij, came 25 years after investigators first confronted him about his World War II past and he admitted lying to get into the U.S. (Source: Department of Justice)

    The White House says a 95-year-old former Nazi concentration camp guard has been deported to Germany, 14 years after a judge ordered him deported.

    The White House says a 95-year-old former Nazi concentration camp guard has been deported to Germany, 14 years after a judge ordered him deported.

  • Woman killed by alligator on Hilton Head Island

    Woman killed by alligator on Hilton Head Island

    Monday, August 20 2018 10:54 PM EDT2018-08-21 02:54:00 GMT

    A woman was attacked and killed by an alligator Monday morning in the Sea Pines area on Hilton Head Island.

    A woman was attacked and killed by an alligator Monday morning in the Sea Pines area on Hilton Head Island.

Powered by Frankly