KFVS12 News & Weather Cape Girardeau, Carbondale, Poplar BluffFamily members ask for help to solve 15 year old cold case

Family members ask for help to solve 15 year old cold case

Posted: Updated:
Dorothy Broozer smiles in a picture with her brother. Dorothy Broozer smiles in a picture with her brother.
At the time of Broozer's death, she had three children.  The oldest was just four years old. At the time of Broozer's death, she had three children. The oldest was just four years old.
  • Heartland News

  • Wednesday, May 23 2012 12:30 AM EDT2012-05-23 04:30:43 GMT
    By Arnold Wyrick - bio | email CARBONDALE, IL (KFVS) - Recently Carbondale was listed as one of the top one hundred cities for crime in America. It's not a title that city leaders are proud of. And it's
    CARBONDALE, IL (KFVS) - Recently Carbondale was listed as one of the top one hundred cities for crime in America.

    It's not a title that city leaders are proud of. And it's one that they're working on getting rid of.
  • LATE BREAKING

    Tuesday, May 22 2012 11:45 PM EDT2012-05-23 03:45:25 GMT
    One person ended up in the hospital after a shooting in Carbondale Tuesday night. According to police the shooting happened at a apartment in the 600 block of Robert A Stalls Avenue. Right now it's not
    According to police the shooting happened at a apartment in the 600 block of Robert A Stalls Avenue.
  • Tuesday, May 22 2012 11:29 PM EDT2012-05-23 03:29:18 GMT
    What if we told you a convicted murderer lives on your street? How would you feel? Now an Illinois registry tells you where convicted killers are living and we found almost a dozen in the Heartland. Holly
    What if we told you a convicted murderer lives on your street? How would you feel? Now an Illinois registry tells you where convicted killers are living and we found almost a dozen in the Heartland.
  • Tuesday, May 22 2012 9:14 PM EDT2012-05-23 01:14:43 GMT
    Gayle Kaler and Robert Coleman won the Paducah mayor race in the Kentucky primary.
    Gayle Kaler and Robert Coleman won the Paducah mayor race in the Kentucky primary.
  • Tuesday, May 22 2012 8:35 PM EDT2012-05-23 00:35:51 GMT
    Mitt Romney is looking to pad his lead in the race for convention delegates in Republican presidential primaries Tuesday in Arkansas and Kentucky, moving ever closer to the nomination he's all but certain to win.
    Mitt Romney has won the Kentucky Republican presidential primary, inching closer to the GOP nomination for president.
  • Tuesday, May 22 2012 8:34 PM EDT2012-05-23 00:34:41 GMT
    Hundreds of veterans and their families are on a cross-country journey.  It's called the "Run for the Wall" and it came roaring into Mt. Vernon on Tuesday.
    Hundreds of veterans and their families are on a cross-country journey.  It's called the "Run for the Wall" and it came roaring into Mt. Vernon on Tuesday.
  • Tuesday, May 22 2012 7:28 PM EDT2012-05-22 23:28:33 GMT
    Special Rangers trained in both law enforcement and the cattle industry join the growing list of authorities searching for missing Florida cattle buyer Ron Shepard. The Texas and Southwestern Cattle Raisers
    Texas authorities trained in the cattle industry join the search for missing Florida cattle buyer Ron Shepard and offer a reward for information leading to his arrest.  The announcement comes on the heels of a three-count indictment handed down Monday accusing Shepard of buying cattle from an East Texas sale barn and then not paying for them.
  • Tuesday, May 22 2012 7:25 PM EDT2012-05-22 23:25:09 GMT
    It's an argument within an argument, is weed safer than alcohol, and if so, should states legalize the drug?
    It's an argument within an argument, is weed safer than alcohol, and if so, should states legalize the drug? A Denver advocacy group is spending thousands of dollars to persuade people to talk about legalizing marijuana.
  • Tuesday, May 22 2012 7:13 PM EDT2012-05-22 23:13:44 GMT
    Funeral arrangements have been set for three children killed in a crash on Interstate 55 near Hayti. Teresa Gaines says the funeral for her three children, Brandaeja Cason, 13, Javon Cason, baby, and
    Funeral arrangements have been set for three children killed in a crash on Interstate 55 near Hayti. Teresa Gaines says the funeral for her three children, Brandaeja Cason, 13, Javon Cason, baby, and
PARMA, MO (KFVS) -

Fifteen years ago a southeast Missouri woman was found dead in her home. But to this day no one has ever been arrested. It's a cold case that has her family asking for your help to solve. Most of all, her kids want to know why someone would kill their mother.

Dorothy Broozer smiles in a picture with her brother. But beyond Broozer's smile lies many questions as to what happened to her so many years ago.

"We always have a hard time this time of year," Geraldine Claytor, Broozer's mother said. "The kids ask questions on a regular basis did they find who killed my mother yet."

At the time Broozer had three children, the oldest just four years old. Once Broozer died, Claytor took on the task of raising her grandchildren.  

"We always talked about it," Broozer said. "That was okay for me because I wanted to know more about what they had to say."

Broozer's children are now in their teens. But tell Heartland News they still remember trying to wake their mom up on the couch of their Parma Missouri home.  They were asleep in the next room when she died.

It's a day Broozer's sister says she also can't get out of her head.

"It was a day of terror, like a horror movie, like this is unbelievable, never ever would I have imagined," Deanna Boozer-Cohen said.  

"There are some cases that really stick with you as an investigator, as a police officer and this one really does with me," New Madrid County Sheriff Terry Stevens said.  

At the time Stevens had been on the job just weeks when his deputies responded to a gunshot call. Steven says over the years they followed up on several leads but never solved the case.

"There's been things that have presented itself over the years that we have pursued out some as far as the state of Wisconsin, but nothing that has presented itself that's been fruitful," Stevens said.

Stevens says they have also had suspects but never enough evidence for an arrest.

Still in a town of just over 800, Broozer's family believes someone in Parma knows what happened to Dorothy.

"I want to be able to get on with just celebrating her life. It's like a mixture; we can't just celebrate her life. It has to be mixed with this, who did it," Broozer-Cohen said.  

Sheriff Stevens says the case is still open and won't be closed until someone is arrested. Broozer's family asks if you remember anything about the night Dorothy was killed to call the New Madrid County's Sheriff's Office.  

Copyright 2012 KFVS. All Rights Reserved.